iPhone App Review Marathon Liveblog - gizmondo.com
iPhone App Review Marathon Liveblog
There
are a total of 552 different apps in the iPhone App Store right now.
We're going to do live impressions of the best ones (and some really,
really lousy ones if they're interesting enough). Post requests in the comments and check back frequently cause we're updating as we go review more apps.
Twitterific:
Works just like the desktop version of Twitterific (it gives you access
to Twitter), and also uses the iPhone's location-aware features to
geotag your tweets. What it doesn't do, like Twinkle,
is give you a feed of Twitter users from around you. It does, however,
let you attach photos to pics and let you know if your friends Tweet
from a nearby location. Overall, pretty good. Ad-supported version is
Free; Ad-free version is $10.
PhoneSaber:
Lightsaber application similar to the one on Installer.app. Five
choices of iPhone colors and slightly better accelerometer detection
for better lightsaber sounds. Free.
Midomi: Song Recognition App that actually works well enough to know when it's being Rickrolled. Free
iTunes Remote: Remote control your iTunes and iTV. It's very, very good, and can even rate songs directly from the phone. Pretty much the perfect iTunes remote. Free.
NetNewsWire:
Similar to the RSS Reader on the desktop, which we use daily, NNW on
the iPhone lets you read RSS feeds. It doesn't scale images like the
web-based Mac RSS reader, so you're going to have to do a bit of
panning and scrolling. Other than that, no real complaints. It even
syncs with your NNW online account so you can keep your desktop feeds
and iPhone feeds the same (in terms of knowing what you already read).
Free.
Google Mobile:
Location aware searching with auto-suggest, contacts searching as well
as local business search (typing in pizza gives you an option to search
for pizza near you). Unfortunately, as Lifehacker pointed out, it only searches your contacts, not your calendar or email. One step at a time. Free.
Yelp:
Pretty much exactly the same features as the online yelp.com portal,
but in a readable format for your iPhone. Search for pizza places,
coffee shops, bars or gas stations and you'll be able to check out its
hours, the location, the phone number and read reviews. You can drill
down from the home screen to Restaurants, Bars, Coffee & Tea,
Banks, Gas & Service Stations or Drugstores, or just type in
whatever you want. Everyone should download it just to have. Free.
Facebook:
Just like the iPhone-customized Facebook webpage, except crashier
(crashed when I tried to view the friends list the first time). You can
search your friends, do Facebook chat (nice), view your messages and do
everything else you could do on the web-based portal. It just crashed
when I tried to view my profile too. Free.
Pandora:
Your standard internet radio—you pick an artist you like, it recommends
similar songs which you then rate to hone its selections. Like always
it's better for well-known artists, but its explanation for why certain
tracks were picked ("intricate melodic phrasing, a clear focus on
recoding studio production, heartbreaking lyrics") are priceless.
Pandora claims CD-quality but several tracks sounded compressed. A plus
is that streaming works well with very little lag even over EDGE. Album
art comes in with that nice page effect; good thing, because that's all
you'll be seeing since the app can't play in the background. Free. – John Mahoney
IGN Reviews:
Easily get IGN game reviews on the go, either by searching for the game
title or browsing a list of recent reviews. If you don't trust IGN for
reviews, it's not a huge help, but it does give you a decent idea of
what's good and what's not if you're at the game section of Best Buy
looking for something to take home. Free.
Save Benjis:
Think Pricegrabber or Google Products for the iPhone. Search for a
particular product you want and it will throw up a list of prices from
various retailers. Useful for going shopping and not knowing whether
the TV you're buying will be cheaper online (it usually will be).
Mixmeister:
Allows users to perform scratches over the music in their playlist
using one of ten available vinyl scratch sounds. I'm not a DJ, but it
was easy to pick up and get a decent scratch going right away. Bottom
line: it's fun. Free. – Sean Fallon

MotionX-Poker: An addictive dice and poker game that shakes virtual dice by actually sampling your shake of the iPhone and simulating the roll. It's the best original game for the iPhone yet. $5 – Brian Lam
Weight Track
A weight log of how much you weigh every day that syncs w/ the website,
but also gives you a history of your weight loss. Pretty much just a
fancy alternative for a pen and pencil, but not bad if you're trying to
lose some weight. Comes with sluggish graphics and animations. Free.
AIM:
It's as solid as you'd expect, supporting away statuses, marking
contacts as favorites so you can easily find them, groups, away
messages and saved messages while you're away from the app. Because
background IM notifications won't be here until September, you'll have
to go into the app to check whether or not you have new messages.
Still, it's good that you don't lose any. Oh, and that really annoying
traditional AIM sound is still here and is still super freaking
annoying. Don't see a way to turn that off. But there is a system
option to sign off when you exit. Free.
MySpace Mobile:
I have never used MySpace Mobile on another platform, but I can say
that the version for the iPhone is very solid. It ran smooth and
provided easy access to every option you could find on the regular
site. It sure as hell won't make me want to use MySpace again, but
addicts who have an iPhone will undoubtedly be thrilled. Free. – Sean Fallon
Whrrl:
Think Yelp, but more-map based and social networking-like. Go to your
current location and you can see markers signifying places of
restaurants or stores. Click on them to see reviews, write reviews, or
place markers saying that you've been there, wanted to go there or that
you're there now. This could be cool if you have enough friends using
it, but otherwise you're playing around with strangers. Free.
Tiny Violin:
A virtual "world's smallest violin" to play to whiners. It plays two
tunes which get old fast. Much like the idea itself. $1. – Brian Lam
Bejeweled 2:If
you're a fan of the Bejeweled game, you will love this iPhone version.
There are two different game modes, Classic and Action. The only
difference in between the two is Action mode has a time limit. Game
play works as it should, you touch a jewel you want to move then touch
the surrounding spot you want it to move to. There's a Hint feature
that will advise you to the best jewel to move. The game uses full use
of the iPhone's accelerometer, allowing play at any angle. The graphics
and sound FX are great, and overall gameplay is smooth without any
problems. $10. -Chris Mascari
Box Office:
Very simple, incredibly useful—gives you a full list of movie showtimes
sorted by name, your location (manual zipcode entry or GPS/celltower
reading) or Rotten Tomato rating and kicks you to Fandango to buy
tickets. So much better than hitting Google for showtimes in Safari.
Free. -John Mahoney
Dial 0:
A directory of service 800 numbers with instructions on how to reach a
real person for each one, all of them I tried being some variation on
"press 0 over and over again." Kind of handy to have all the numbers
you might need in one place, but not fantastic. Free. -John Mahoney
Band:
Holy Crap this app is fun. There are five different instruments that
all play in landscape mode: Rock Kit, Funky Drummer, Bassist, Grand
Piano, and 12 Bar Blues. It's able to record every instrument one track
at a time, and each time a new instrument is recorded it replays what's
already been recorded. Basically you can make a complete musical
masterpiece one instrument at a time. There's even audience sounds for
added ambiance. While it has the ability to save all your recordings,
sadly there is no way to get those recordings off the iPhone. $10. -Chris Mascari
World 9: Start the app and put it in your pocket. As you run and jump it makes Super Mario brothers noises. Free and awesome. -Brian Lam
Shazam: Will also identify songs through the iPhone's mic—doesn't handle humming and singing as well as Midomi, but is tops at picking up ambient background music. -John Mahoney
AOL Radio:
Features over 200 stations spanning more than 25 genres of music and
over 150 local radio stations from across the US. You can bookmark
favorite stations, artists and even link up to iTunes or AOL music when
you find a song you like. All-in-all it works well. The sound quality
is good, its easy to navigate and you can control the volume right in
the app. It also stops playing when you remove your headphones. You
can't run it in the background, however. Free. -Sean Fallon
Sketches:
The best drawing and photo mockery tool for the iPhone. You can choose
different photo or solid or map backgrounds and drop various icons or
draw on images and export them out. No text tool. A little slow but
worth $8.-Brian Lam>
Comic Touch: Overlay text bubbles on images, and warp faces. Unlike the Sketches app, it has a text tool, but that's it. $5.-Brian Lam>
Crazy Eye:
Yeah, this is a program with 10 animations of different eyeballs
(dragon, pirate, etc) that switch and move around. You're supposed to
hold it up to your face and it's supposed to make you look like a
monster or something. It gets old in about 1 minute and costs a buck. -Brian Lam
AP Mobile News Network:
A great way to browse the wires for news, photos and videos (really
reminds me in a way of the presentation on the Wii, sans the spinning
globe sadly). Videos kick you to YouTube. But am I the only one that
still remembers AP promising some kind of game-changing user-submitted news submission process at WWDC? That seems to be missing in this version, at least. Free. -John Mahoney
Mosquito:
This is an audio/motion game, where you listen to a mosquito buzzing
and when it gets close, you swat it by swinging your iPhone. Clever,
but for $2, there isn't enough pay off. -Brian Lam
Urbanspoon:
If you're hungry but don't know where you want to eat, Urbanspoon makes
finding a restaurant pretty fun. It's like a slot machine, listing
neighborhoods, cuisines and price ranges in the three columns. When you
shake the iPhone, it spins the wheels, delivering a random restaurant
to you. You can lock on any or all three of the columns to get
something more specific if you want, and clicking the restaurant name
brings you to more info about it. Could be fun if you aren't the
pre-planning type. Free. -Adam Frucci
Etch-a-Sketch:
The Etch-a-Sketch game is essentially a doodling app, allowing you to
draw free-form with your fingers on the touchscreen, changing the
colors and other such things using the controls at the bottom. If
you're a purist, you can use the knobs, but that's just as annoying as
it is when you're using the real thing. As you can see by my
masterpiece above, doing it freehand lets you use separate lines and
you can really make great stuff that you can then send to your
friends/boss. Just like with a real Etch-a-Sketch, you erase simply by
shaking. $4.99. -Adam Frucci
NY Times Viewer:
Basically the same as the AP viewer—but seems a little more clunkily
implemented (it's slow, images don't always load, crashed a few times
during test). Not as much video. But still a nice way to grab news for
reading offline. Free. -John Mahoney
Telegram:
This is the only app I didn't buy before writing a review. The $10 app
promises to send voice messages between people on your friend list or
email. I call it expensive visual email. -Brian Lam
iZen Garden:
Ok, I lied, I didn't review this either. Here's a Zen rock garden game
for $8. Last time I checked rocks and dirt were free, so fake rocks and
dirt should also be free. -Brian Lam
Graffitio:
This is supposedly a location aware app that allows you to leave
virtual message boards according to your location. You can go to a
restaurant and say, "the eggs are great!" and the next user. It's free
but I wasn't impressed yet. -Brian Lam
South Park Imaginationland:
Help Butters through Imaginationland by making him jump on mushrooms,
collect rainbows, and fly. It's even worse than it sounds; the controls
suck and by the time I figured out how to play, I was already bored.
Still, the sound effects are great and I love South Park, so let me
know when there's a Fingerbang game. $10. -Benny Goldman
Battle of Waterloo:
This is a choose your own adventure text game. About the battle of
Waterloo. "Join the Infantry!" or "Lie Down and Take Cover!" Either
way, "Save Your $4 Bucks!" $4 -John Mahoney
Routsey San Francisco:
Basically a Next Muni app for your iPhone. You select the SF Muni line
you are interested in, and based off your location it will show you the
closest stop with arrival times. For some reason the app displays the
schedule for the closest stop only. So there is no way to check info
for a stop you are not near. $3. -Chris Mascari
LifeGame: Based on Conway's Game of Life,
this must be the easiest game ever; simply press play, and it runs
itself. Watch and be mesmerized as patterns of black dots form into...
something. We're still not quite sure what we're watching, but it looks
sweet, like a binary iTunes visualizer. Make and play your own patterns
for extra fun. Free. -Benny Goldman
MPG:
MPG lets you keep track of how often you fill up your tank and how much
you're spending on gas, just in case you somehow forgot. It's slow as
hell on the phone we're testing it on, even though it's a pretty
simple, but that might just be because we've overloaded this poor
iPhone with apps. When it does work, it lets you keep track of your MPG
from tank to tank. If you're working on hypermiling, you can find out
just how efficient you've been since the last fillup and see how much
you've cut back on your driving. $0.99 -Adam Frucci
Zen Pinball: Rollercoaster
is a pretty straightforward pinball game. The graphics are nice, and
it's pretty smooth. Essentially, you tap the right side of the screen
for the right bumper, the left side for the left bumper, and flick on
the ball release to fire another ball. You can nudge the table by
shaking the phone as well. It's fun enough, but you'd be hard pressed
to find this exciting for more than a few minutes. $4.99 -Adam Frucci
Bomberman Touch: The Legend of Mystic Bomb:
The developers who totally nail traditional d-pad-plus-two-buttons
controls for iPhone games will do everyone a favor—sadly, Bomberman
hasn't. Your thumb blocks your Bomberman more than it should. Plus
after the first level anyway, gameplay is too slow—not nearly frantic
enough to rival the classics. $8. -John Mahoney
Aqua Forest:
This water moving game uses both the touchscreen and accelerometer of
the iPhone for controls. With five different categories, Tilting,
Touch, Drawing, Warm/Cold, and All Functions there are 50 different
puzzles that require either tilting, touching or both. There is even a
Free mode, where you can create your own little atmosphere of stuff
like water, fire and ice, and then by tilting/shaking the iPhone you
can mix it all up. -Chris Mascari
Mobile Flickr:
Full-featured Flickr app, you can browse your photos by sets, tags, and
more. Photo browsing is comparable to the iPhone's built in browser,
and you can even assign a picture to a contact. It was slow to take
pics and save them, but uploading to Flickr over Wi-Fi was fast. The
only problem? The picture was upside down on Flickr! $3. -Benny Goldman
Exposure:
This app is just designed for looking at Flickr pics, and has no upload
feature. It shows recent pictures taken by others near your location
which is cool, but browsing was slow and it only shows one picture per
line. Skip this app, it's worth shelling out the $3 for Mobile Flickr,
especially when Exposure Premium costs $10 and only removes an ad
banner. Free. -Benny Goldman
CityTransit:
The undisputed king of the NYC subway map apps. It's the only one with
the officially licensed maps, it'll plot your nearest subway stations
on a Google Map for easier navigation, includes service advisories,
includes LIRR and Metro North as well as an antique map, looks
beautiful—does it all. And at $2.99 it's the cheapest—don't touch the
other two, especially the $15 one. $3. -John Mahoney
Alarm Free:
Alarm Free is a pretty simple, and pretty stupid, app. Basically, it's
a picture of an alarm. If you shake your phone, the alarm goes off and
makes an annoying noise. Touch the screen to make it stop. Apparently,
it's designed as a self-defense program, and you're supposed to hold it
up to an attacker to scare them off. If you hold this up to an
attacker, they will steal your iPhone, then probably give you an extra
hard beating for assuming they were dumb enough to be scared by
flashing lights on your phone. Free. -Adam Frucci
GuitarToolKit:
A companion app for your guitar that has many different tuning pre-sets
(it detects sound via your iPhone's mic), standard tone generation, a
metronome and chords. Tuning my bass guitar that I've been too lazy to
tune for a year and a half was fast and easy, and the tone generation
was useful to remember which note each string was supposed to be.
Chords and metronome will be great when I get around to playing it
again. $9.99 is about the price of a cheap tuner, but this is even
better since you have your iPhone with you always.
All reviews written by Jason Chen, unless otherwise noted.